Tufts Edition
| Name | Overall | Taste | Creativity | Value |
| Davis Square Hand Crafted Donuts & Bagels | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Demet’s Coffee and Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Donuts with a Difference | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Lyndell’s Bakery | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Mass Hole Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| When Pigs Fly | –- | –- | –- | –- |
Expansion Pack 1
| Name | Overall | Taste | Creativity | Value |
| Blackbird Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Donut Villa Diner | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Doughboy Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Gail Ann Coffee Shop | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Kane’s Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Rosebud Kitchen | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Sofra Bakery and Cafe | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Union Square Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
New England
| Name | Overall | Taste | Creativity | Value |
| Holy Donut | 4.3 | 4.3 | 3.3 | 4.0 |
San Francisco
| Name | Overall | Taste | Creativity | Value |
| All Stars - Clement St | 3.0 | 3.0 | 1.0 | 5.0 |
| Bob's Donuts | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 4.0 |
| Donut World | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Golden Donuts | 3.0 | 3.0 | 1.0 | 5.0 |
| Mochill Mochi Donut | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| O'Henry's Donuts | 5.0 | 4.0 | 2.0 | 5.0 |
Japan
| Name | Overall | Taste | Creativity | Value |
| And Tokyo | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Donuts Record | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Dumbo Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Higuma Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Jack in the Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Mister Donut | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Oscar Wilde Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
All
| Name | Overall | Taste | Creativity | Value |
| All Stars - Clement St | 3.0 | 3.0 | 1.0 | 5.0 |
| And Tokyo | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Blackbird Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Bob's Donuts | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 4.0 |
| Davis Square Hand Crafted Donuts & Bagels | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Demet’s Coffee and Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Donut Villa Diner | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Donut World | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Donuts Record | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Donuts with a Difference | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Doughboy Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Dumbo Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Gail Ann Coffee Shop | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Golden Donuts | 3.0 | 3.0 | 1.0 | 5.0 |
| Higuma Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Holy Donut | 4.3 | 4.3 | 3.3 | 4.0 |
| Jack in the Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Kane’s Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| La Donutserie | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Lyndell’s Bakery | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Mass Hole Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Mister Donut | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Mochill Mochi Donut | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| O'Henry's Donuts | 5.0 | 4.0 | 2.0 | 5.0 |
| Oscar Wilde Doughnuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Rosebud Kitchen | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Sofra Bakery and Cafe | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| Union Square Donuts | –- | –- | –- | –- |
| When Pigs Fly | –- | –- | –- | –- |